A Deeply Human and Beautiful Tale: The Best Historical Film of 2024

In a year filled with cinematic offerings, one historical film has captured the hearts of audiences, earning a remarkable rating of 4.2 out of 5 on AlloCiné. This animated feature, which has moved many to tears, stands out as a poignant exploration of a dark chapter in history.

While films addressing the Holocaust are numerous, few resonate as profoundly as "La Plus Précieuse des marchandises," directed by Michel Hazanavicius. Released in November 2024, this film has struck a chord with viewers, garnering 3,928 ratings and 348 reviews, solidifying its status as the best historical film of the year. Much of its acclaim stems from the emotional weight carried throughout its narrative and its delicate visuals, which starkly contrast the violence of its historical backdrop.

A Heart-Wrenching Story of Humanity During the Holocaust

Departing from the lighthearted tones of "The Artist" and "OSS 117," Hazanavicius ventures into the realm of animation for the first time with this touching tale, adapted from Jean-Claude Grumberg's 2019 novel of the same name. The story unfolds during World War II in Poland, where a woodcutter discovers a baby abandoned near the train tracks, having been thrown from a deportation train. By taking in this infant, she irrevocably alters her life, her husband’s, and the fates of all who encounter them. Just reading this premise evokes tears.

2020 EX NIHILO - LES COMPAGNONS DU CINEMA - STUDIOCANAL - FRANCE 3 CINEMA - LES FILMS DU FLEUVE

Hazanavicius skillfully navigates the tragedy of history without succumbing to melodrama. His challenge is met with stunning imagery of snow-covered forests and the tender interactions between a couple and the baby. This unsettling contrast between the brutality of the era and the film's focus on humanity is what makes it so impactful.

Despite being nominated for three César awards—Best Adaptation, Best Animated Film, and Best Original Score—"La Plus Précieuse des marchandises" did not win any, a disappointment for many who believe it deserved recognition. The film was also featured at the Cannes Film Festival but failed to attract sufficient attention from the jury. Nevertheless, for AlloCiné audiences, it is unequivocally the best historical film of 2024.

Audience Reactions

Cinefeed commented, "A deeply human and beautiful film. The simplicity of the narrative and the drawings magnificently serve this tale."

Karen T. expressed, "A masterpiece of humanity! There are many stories about the Holocaust, but this one, showcasing genuine human hearts during such an inhumane period, is essential. This film must be shown to new generations urgently!"

Guillebotis noted, "Exceptional work on the visuals and sound design (the muffled sound of snow makes you feel as if you are there), combining intelligence and beauty without any complacency or sentimentality. An absolute success."

Claude Julien57 remarked, "A very powerful film with exceptional voices, the narrative reaches its conclusion with a chilling yet truthful commentary by Jean-Louis Trintignant. So many emotions! The audience applauded at the end!"

Ralexenc stated, "Tears, joy, darkness, and light coexist in this story where it’s hard not to shed a tear."

Bruneaupaul urged, "Don’t miss this masterpiece. The animation is incredibly refined, and the story is brutally realistic. All young people must see it."